Corruption in the Vermont Youth Orchestra

Posted

The Vermont Youth Orchestra Organization is the only orchestra association in Vermont and is the center for music for many children across Vermont. However, ever since last year the organization is showing signs of corruption throughout the way it operates.

The first round of seating auditions was on September 15th, 2019 for the 2019-20 season. After the seating audition process had been finished, results were out a week later. Each audition has two judges/adjudicators, who judge each person's playing and give them a score, one being the conductor and the other being a guest adjudicator. The issue here is that people with higher marks and scores on the auditions were placed in the back of the section while the people with lower marks were moved to the front of the sections. This was apparent throughout almost all of the string sections. 

I've compiled direct quotations from fellow members of the Vermont Youth Orchestra's string and wind sections regarding the seating auditions.

"It just doesn't make any sense. I compared my scores to the scores of everyone who was placed in a better seat than I was... but I had higher marks than both of them."

"The whole system is corrupt, and this just confirmed what I thought. It's not right that (redacted) has a higher score and plays better overall but got placed almost last while (redacted) got first chair."

"Things were better last year. The system was fair, and people got the seatings they deserved."

'I've had many different conductors throughout my orchestra career, and I'm not sure what to make of our current conductor. It seems to me that he has some favoritism going on."

"Why should she be in front of me? I had the higher score and I can prove it."

The interesting thing regarding the unfair seating chart after the auditions was that all the people sitting at the front were connected in some way to the staff of the VYOA. There are many who sat up front who are students of some of the staff of the Vermont Youth Orchestra, which begs the question- Is there politics and corruption going around? And given the correlation between the people sitting up front and their relations to staff in the VYOA, the answer is clearly yes. Another interesting statistic is to view the donor list of the VYOA. An interesting thing to be noted is that the children of donors who donated significantly more than others were among the people sitting in the front, despite receiving a lower score than the others sitting in the back  (I confirmed this with the people from each section and their scoresheets.) So is that what the VYOA is now?  A pay- to- succeed based organization? I was fortunate enough to speak with the guest adjudicator from an audition once regarding the seating auditions and who ultimately decided the final seating chart. They stated that the other adjudicator, the conductor gets final say in the seating chart. That's where the issue begins. While the conductor may have spent more time with the students outside of the single audition to know generally who the stronger students are, they can have a bias toward certain students. It's important to have an unbiased set of eyes judge each student so the score is unbiased. But since the conductor gets final say in the seating chart, does it matter anyways? What's the point of having a guest adjudicator if their ideas are shot down so easily? Another point that's important is that the guest adjudicator should not have the ability to judge their own students. This has happened multiple times in the past few seating auditions, including the first audition for VYOA applications this 2019-20 season. This was also an issue with the Vermont Allstate Music Festival for the past few years, especially last year. 

Also, there's a definite flaw with the audition system. First, if a person misses seating audition day, they must send a video (recording) of them performing the selected excerpts for the audition. But what does this mean? It means that someone could record themselves multiple times, over and over again until they get a near perfect recording and send it to the VYOA. In essence, the people are getting unlimited tries on their audition while everyone else only gets one. How is this fair to anyone else who shows up, physically on seating audition day and gets only one shot at the audition, especially with the pressure of performing live? 

I am not the only one who's outraged about this whole incident. An orchestra should be fair, without bias when deciding who sits up front and who sits in back, but the VYO doesn't seems like it follows that general rule. I've even heard parents complaining about the auditions being heavily corrupt. I am submitting this to the Essex Reporter because I've made complaints about this to the VYOA, and they've done nothing to make the system fair. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here