[The Village of Essex Junction is an incorporated municipality within the Town of Essex. The governments of the two municipalities, the Town and the Village, have been consolidating services and departments since 2013, and are now exploring the concept of a complete merger.]
FAQ: How is this merger effort different?
A frequent question is how the current merger effort differs from past efforts. If voters rejected a Village-Town consolidation proposal in 2007, why should they vote for one now?
First, and most important, there was no legacy of cooperation between the two governments in 2007. The Essex Junction Board of Trustees and Essex Town Selectboard rarely sat at the same table to collaborate on solving problems of mutual interest.
Each government had its own manager, its own administrative staff, its own finance department. Essex Junction had a Village clerk who oversaw governmental affairs and elections; Essex Town had a Town clerk who did the same. Moreover, an attempt by the Trustees seven years earlier to entirely separate from the Town, and no longer be part of its tax base, had been thwarted by the Selectboard’s counter effort to consolidate the two governments. The net result was not only to maintain the status quo, but to fuel an atmosphere of resentment and suspicion.
When the two sides finally sat down in 2007 to discuss a possible merger, an atmosphere of mistrust still prevailed. The merger committee they selected approached their job as if it were a competitive negotiation between two rivals; the committee membership was scrupulously balanced between Town-inside-the-Village and Town-outside-the-Village residents so that neither side would appear to have an advantage. The merger proposal they produced met the state’s legal requirements but left much to the imagination, creating an information vacuum that merger opponents were happy to fill with their own biases. No thought had been given to buffering the financial impacts of merger. The name of the new community, ‘Town of Essex Junction,’ which pleased no one, was borne of negotiating compromise and not common sense. The new government might be located at Lincoln Hall, but maybe not. No one could say how it would work, which manager and other staff would be kept on, how efficiency would be improved. Many messy details were left to be worked out post-merger.
It probably shouldn’t have come as a surprise when opponents of the merger only needed to scratch the surface of Town-Village tribalism to cause the merger to fail. The two governments shared little common ground and had no base of trust to build on.
But they began to build that base of trust several years later when the Village asked the Town to help finance a new fire truck that would belong to the Essex Junction Fire Department but serve the entire community. The Town agreed.
They followed this by jointly sponsoring a shared services study that outlined how consolidating various Town and Village departments might save money while maintaining services at their present levels. They began successfully putting these ideas to the test in 2013 when the Village manager left and the Town manager became the ‘unified’ manager for both governments. This was soon followed by unifying the Town and Village finance departments, clerks, and management support staff. The Town and Village boards cleared a major financial and political hurdle when they forged an agreement to have the financing of the Village highway department come from the Town general fund, thereby distributing the costs of street and sidewalk maintenance evenly throughout the community.
When the new unified manager came on board he led further efforts to consolidate interdepartmental policies and procedures, simplifying processes and improving efficiency. A recent example is co-locating the Town and Village recreation offices in the same building. Most important, municipal staff supported the Town Selectboard and Village Trustees holding regular joint meetings. These joint meetings, which have been happening for two years now, have strengthened the positive relationship between elected officials and continue to build trust as we work more closely together for the benefit of both communities.
The present merger effort evolved from discussions at these joint board meetings. Unlike the 2007 effort, the boards have taken great pains to solicit input from the entire community about the structure of local government, how elections should be run, how tax impacts should be minimized, how issues of identity and concerns about development might be addressed.
The present merger discussion rests on a base of trust the Selectboard and Trustees started building over ten years ago. Despite claims by some that a merger proposal is a done deal, it’s still very much a work in progress. We’re still gathering community input and we’ll be listening to constituents at Town and Village annual meetings next spring. If, after all that, the boards approve a merger plan and charter change proposal for November 2020, we’ll be able to answer most voters’ questions about how it will work, and show how consolidation efforts over the last ten years have already saved money and maintained good services.
Most important is the hope that the sincere efforts of both boards to make Town-Village rivalry a thing of the past will provide the confidence voters need to feel that merger is a step in the right direction.
---
Results of the second resident survey are currently being compiled. You’ll find a link to the results of the first survey--and much more--on www.GreaterEssex2020.org. Stay tuned for next week’s column, and as always, send your questions, thoughts, and concerns to us at ehaney@essex.org, abrown@essexjunction.org, and eteich@essex.org.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here