ESSEX TOWN AND JUNCTION — Formed two years ago, the Essex Police Community Advisory Board aims to bridge the gap between the community and its police department.
The PCAB came together to perform outreach and policy review, and to address issues like race-based discrimination, after the murder of George Floyd in 2020 and the rise of the nationwide Black Lives Matter movement.
“They basically said, ‘Let's try and at least figure out what we can do better in our town and city, since there's so much going on in the world on this topic,’” said resident board chair Christina Hagestad. “And I speak my mind, I wanted to do some activism. This seemed like a good way.”
According to the town and city websites, the Essex PCAB’s mission is to facilitate a “positive, trusting and effective relationship” between the community of Essex and Essex Junction and the Essex Police Department, and to “advocate for the systemically marginalized, disenfranchised and oppressed members of the community,” providing honest feedback to law enforcement.
The board spent its first year establishing a foundation, reviewing policies, building relationships with community organizations like the Howard and Community Justice Centers, and navigating a lot of turnover. Now, its sights are set on turning resident feedback into actionable change.
“It’s been going well,” Hagestad said. “There were a lot of hot button topics, basically talking about discrimination and race — and I love that our group is so diverse. Even the members who have come and gone have all added really amazing perspectives.”
The PCAB has included people who are and aren’t immigrants, people with visible and invisible disabilities, people from different socioeconomic backgrounds, careers and education statuses, people with mixed feelings about the police department, people who are LGBTQ+ like Hagestad herself, as well as folks from other marginalized groups.
Its current biggest project? Developing a new community survey to gather public opinions on the state of and effectiveness of community policing in the town and city today. The team hopes to get that out in the coming weeks or months, and once the data collection phase is complete, the results will be used to guide the department on what can be improved going forward.
This project was inspired by a similar survey done by a committee known as “Essex Best” back in 2020, which gave rise to and has since been absorbed by the community liaison board, Essex PCAB. The goals of both groups have been similar, with respect to equity in policing.
The Reporter obtained the original survey from 2021, see below:
Some of the main takeaways from just over 600 respondents were that over 70% of total participants at the time reported positive experiences with EPD, which changes based on race, with the majority of BIPOC participants reporting having had both positive and negative experiences.
BIPOC respondents were more likely to report negative experiences with EPD than white respondents, and police have reportedly been weaponized against BIPOC members, with racial targeting by local police an existent problem in the Essex area, according to the survey’s results.
The PCAB as a citizen oversight board came about in response to needs identified by the initial survey. Copies in PDF-form featuring enhanced formatting are available at EPD upon request.
The language of the new survey has yet to be finalized, but with an anticipated release coming soon, will include questions on safety, police interactions, community resources and more, to gather data on topics like safety, discrimination and satisfaction with the local policing approach.
The board has spent months refining the survey questions to ensure clarity, inclusivity and effectiveness of insights they intend to gather. Once out, it will be disseminated through QR codes, flyers, news and social media, and perhaps town and city websites and newsletters.
Police Chief Ron Hoague is typically present at PCAB meetings, primarily as a listener, and to offer pressure-free guidance and perspective. He regularly updates the PCAB about his department's recent hires, programs and challenges. Also present is community liaison officer Alyssa March.
However, it is important to note the PCAB is and remains independent of the department.
Although meetings are public and feature a police-presence, residents are encouraged to still reach out to the board to talk privately to discuss any sort of distressing or concerning police interaction, Hagestad said.
Setting up a time to talk in-person is the most secure way to chat if privacy is desired.
The board is also in search of two new members for seats currently open. This is a volunteer committee which offers a $50 stipend to cover childcare and travel time for meeting attendance.
The PCAB email is EPD.AdvisoryBoard@essex.org and Hagestad’s is chagestad@essex.org.
If you’re looking to be in touch with someone from EPD directly and without anonymity, liaison officer Alyssa March is at amarch@essex.org or folks can call the department at 802-878-1335.
A blog of PCAB-related updates can be followed here.
“I’m really excited about our survey,” Hagestad said. “We want the best data… The most accurate, perfect data that we can get, so we can do the most with what we’re getting.”
She hopes this survey can drill down on specifics — for instance, if an overwhelming number of residents say they feel unsafe, the PCAB would dig into why, and orchestrate perhaps a self-defense course, gun lock distribution programs or direct folks to social and community resources to help with that.
While the old Essex Best survey was more focused on racial discrimination in policing, Hagestad said the PCAB’s approach will cover that but also be more broad, with questions for everyone about how safe they feel living or working in Essex, rating their experiences with the EPD, sharing call times and disclosing how professional, courteous and responsive local officers have been.
Stay tuned at essexreporter.com for survey details upon its near-future release.