ESSEX JUNCTION — The city’s governance committee, established a year ago to study key aspects of municipal governance and recommend potential charter updates, has dissolved.
It left the city council to review its final report and recommendations this past Wednesday.
The governance committee’s recommended charter changes, which the council agreed to add as itemized questions on this year’s Annual Meeting ballot, are as follows:
Increase councilor stipends from $2,500 to $3,600
Provide the council president 25% higher compensation
Automatically increase annual council stipends in line with the Consumer Price Index
Require a comprehensive charter review every 12 years
The CPI is a measure of the average change over time in prices paid by urban consumers for a market basket of consumer goods and services, according to the U.S. bureau of labor statistics.
These questions will appear in some iteration on the ballot this April. Precise language of these general line items will be approved at a later council meeting, with input from the city’s attorney.
This committee was established as a part of the city’s effort to take stock of its existing systems and redefine or update them as needed, to best represent the interests of city residents, in the wake of Essex Junction’s split from the Town of Essex just a few years back.
The governance committee also recommended retaining the council-manager form of government, keep at-large elections in place, continue with a president elected by councilors, maintain five councilors, maintain three-year staggered terms and maintain no term limit — all of which the city council felt comfortable with.
Items for future exploration include soft reforms to strengthen engagement and participation, such as neighborhood assemblies, as well as examining a recall provision for elected officials.
“The big takeaway is we're focusing on the structural reforms, not some of the soft things,” said Steve Eustis, who served as the governance committee chair. “A lot of math and that went into the counselor stipends. We've had long discussions on this one.”
Although several councilors mentioned they felt uncomfortable discussing their own stipends at all, Eustis and his committee’s vice chair, Marlon Verasamy, both reiterated that adding the committee’s recommendation as its own ballot item takes it entirely out of the council’s hands — putting it instead in the hands of voters to decide.
“And theoretically, you know, it takes a staff a short number of minutes to look that up,” Eustis said. “It's a standard thing that everybody knows about, and then we don't have to waste time debating it every number of years, or potential conflict of interest, or perception of conflict.”
City Council Vice President Marcus Certa thanked the committee for its hard work over the course of this past year, but noted he felt there was a lack of meaningful community engagement that went into the change recommendations, which he found slightly concerning.
But despite relatively low turnout for actual voluntary participation by community members, committee leaders said they made every effort to engage folks throughout the process.
“My personal opinion was the committee went above and beyond, worked really hard to get as many people — they attended different types of events, different times of day, virtual, in-person, different venues, ‘Let's have a community group…’” Eustis said. “I was very impressed with what the community did. We had the call-in, the survey… We gave a ton of opportunities.”
“I mean, I agree,” he added. “I'd love to have another 200 people participate. You can always take these types of things a couple different ways. People aren't very concerned about it, and so they're not going to tune in. They think like, ‘Hey, they got a committee of nine people. They dug in. I'm fine with that.’ Or, they have other priorities they are dealing with.”
Verasamy echoed some of Eustis’ sentiments.
“You guys know this from your perspective as the council, and from my perspective on the school board: Getting engagement is hard. It is. It requires a lot of work, requires a lot of trial and error,” Verasamy said. “When things are going well, people don't engage. They're focused on day-to-day life. And we understand it's hard to get folks excited about this.”
The ultimate check-in, to find out how people really feel about all this, will be at the ballot box, Eustis said. The language of the questions will be finalized for the ballot and scheduled for adoption to it by the city council at its Jan. 21 meeting.
The full, approximately 100-page report, can be found in the council’s Dec. 10 meeting packet.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here