Cell phones and facilities: ESWD school board grapples with policy

Posted

ESSEX WESTFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT — The ESWD school board of directors grappled with facility care and cell phone usage in the district at its May 12 meeting. 

Here’s what to know. 

Caring for aging facilities 

90% of the district’s facilities were built over 50 years ago, Randy Burnett, a consultant from Colin P. Lindberg architects, said. Currently, the school board is in the process of assessing each of the 19 buildings’ needs in relation to their most common usages. It would take an estimated $7 million to make repairs and bring the buildings up to renewal, or a state similar to when they were first built without improvements. 

EWSD is in the second phase of researching how to renew the buildings so that students can continue to use them safely. This second phase collected data on how the buildings are used and what they are most likely to be used for. The first phase established a baseline to review and update building plans and created a district-wide database for findings. 

The second phase found how students, teachers and the community use the buildings varies greatly between the schools and age groups. The majority of the buildings are mostly composed of small instructional spaces or spaces for special instruction. Many schools largely rely on smaller rooms for individual classes.

“It’s the future of education. It’s an opportunity,” Burnett said. “[...] if we know we need to fix some things, let’s study it and study it the right way and include everybody.” 

The third phase would involve concept design and cost modeling, which would first require talking with stakeholders, including students, teachers and other persons who heavily use the facilities. It would refine program needs based on smaller group sessions with individuals by age and grade. 

Debating the district facilities policy 

The board also voted to amend a proposed facility policy that dictates protocol for allowing groups unaffiliated with the district to use the schools as well as the repercussions for negative actions, such as vandalism. 

The board debated disciplinary action for groups which damage facilities as well as the district's ability to deny anyone who practices hateful or discriminatory practices from using the spaces. 

Member Christine Gaynor-Patterson asked the board for clarification on if a significant incident occurred, one time, what would happen to the perpetrator since more severe consequences, such as permanent suspension, are only given for repeated violations. 

The board determined the facilities policy as it stands would be amended within the policy committee before the board reviews it for another first reading and eventual approval to clarify who is allowed to use the spaces and consequences for significant actions. 

The amendments would likely include adding a clause that the superintendent, if approved by the board, would be able to deny facility usage to individuals who do not abide by the district's equity and inclusion policy. The policy committee would likely clarify the procedure for consequences as to allow the district to evaluate if an individual instance warrants a more severe repercussion. 

Cell phones usage during the school day

Cell phone usage during the school day is an increasingly difficult topic to address. Students rely on cell phones to contact parents and make after school plans. The devices also serve as a distraction. 

In 2025, the Vermont legislature passed 16 V.S.A. § 583, stating students are not to use cell phones during the school day, with specific exceptions. 

Although schools must abide by the regulation, they are allowed to make minor adjustments with regards to procedure, or how they carry out the policy. 

EWSD Superintendent Mark Holodick said some districts provide students with pouches to keep their phones in during the day. He shared concerns with spending money on something students might not use.

“We’re not doing anything to show them how to be better users,” board clerk and Westford representative Anne Marie Sharp said. “I would really love to see a responsibility of advocacy of teaching kids more about technology. They’re going to have it for the rest of their lives.” 

The board left the meeting with the goal of finalizing the cell phone policy before the start of the next school year. 

Essex Town representative Laura Taylor said as a high school teacher herself, the cell phone policy would be difficult to enforce, but working with students, parents and other teachers to determine the procedural aspect of the state policy would make it easier to manage. 

“This puts schools in a really difficult spot,” Taylor said.

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here