After hearing public concern at its June 6 meeting, the Essex Jct. Capital Program Review Committee will re-rank the Lamoille Street roadway construction project at its Aug. 1 meeting.
The committee, which is responsible for prioritizing capital projects costing $10,000 or more, currently has five projects on its FY18 schedule, with 24 remaining. As of right now, the Lamoille Street roadway construction, which will entail replacing the existing, undersized waterline and redoing the roadway, is 15th on the list.
At the early June meeting, Lamoille St. resident Patricia Eno expressed concern with the road’s “poor” condition, telling the committee it was rough for residents. She also raised the issue of potential cross-contamination between water and sewer lines, as well as the worry the street’s condition might devalue property.
Addressing Eno’s concerns, committee member Rick Hamlin said cross-contamination between sewer and waterlines is rare. For that to happen, he said at the meeting, there would have to be leakage from both lines and the pressure would have to be off.
He also said the village has video of every sewer line and monitors them. Eno asked Hamlin to confirm the last time this happened.
In terms of the road condition impacting property value, chairman Andrew Brown said the committee has no data defining the relationship between the two, but he said he’s aware of two homes that were sold on the street within months of being put up for sale.
Because the committee re-ranked all the capital projects over the course of four months from January to April due to three new members joining, Brown said, the Aug. 1 re-ranking would set a precedent of doing this out-of-cycle, member Kevin Collins pointed out at the meeting.
Member Tim Dall said the committee should be able re-rank projects when it encounters “extenuating circumstances.”
“One of the things agreed upon is that a petition or significant showing from public if something like this happens, or a grant opportunity comes up, that could change the ranking criteria,” Brown said.
In that same vein, Brown said the committee plans to officially define what it considers to be “extenuating circumstances,” and added that in his opinion, a show of public support or disinterest in a project should have sway with the committee.
Brown said he will also draft a letter for Lamoille Street residents informing them the project will be re-ranked.
To decide the order in which capital projects will be completed, the committee uses a rubric based on 11 factors including safety and health, mandates, community support, financing sourcing and alignment with village priorities.
Each component has a maximum point score, with highest possible total score for a project being 162. The top three factors taken into consideration have a maximum score of 28, 26 and 24 respectively.
Although community support has the third highest potential point score, Brown said it is unique from other considerations.
“Out of possible 24, each project starts at 12 and will go up and down depending on public support,” he said. “We wanted to encourage public support and reward it. “
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here