Near the end of a meeting filled with emotions, the Essex Westford school board passed the district equity policy, 8-1.
The policy seeks to ensure “all students are provided with what they need in support of their academic, social-emotional and career development.”
Elizabeth Cady, an outspoken critic of the district’s equity work, was the only board member to vote no. Though the policy was crafted over the course of nine months, she thought the process was rushed and said opponents were disregarded.
At its height, last night’s Zoom meeting had 148 participants. During public forum, many community members unmuted to encourage the board to vote yes, no, or to postpone the vote.
The board’s student representatives, Iris Hsiang and Tilly Krishna, also spoke up to share their own opinions as well as the student body’s.
“Students often don’t know what the board is doing, but overwhelmingly, this is the thing students have tuned into the most,” Krishna said. “Students are talking about it in the hallways, in the bathrooms — this is super important to students.”
As student representatives, Hsiang and Krishna could not vote, but Hsiang spoke passionately, encouraging board members to support her lived experience.
“Tilly [Krishna] and I are the only people of color on this board, and we cannot vote,” she said. “We are supportive of this policy.”
The June 15 meeting was the board’s third reading of the policy, which was first written in September 2020 and has since gone through a number of revisions.
The policy’s most recent changes include, but are not limited to, a statement committing EWSD to ongoing education around this issue and a note that the policy shall be tracked and reported quarterly to the board and to the community.
The approved policy creates an Equity Advisory Committee, which will work to translate the policy into actionable classroom practices.
The policy’s most significant revision is the deletion of all procedures, like the instructions for the Equity Advisory Committee’s representation, selection, meeting structure and administrative support.
“Procedure is written by administrators, and then it is shared with the board,” Superintendent Beth Cobb said.
Member Scott Brown was still concerned about the administration’s intent to have 80% of the Equity Advisory Committee be BIPOC. He believed race should not be a determining factor for member selection.
Hsiang rebutted him by saying BIPOC voices are systematically silenced, and this committee is an opportunity to right that wrong.
“I don’t want anything about us to be happening without us,” she said.
Cobb did not promise a change to the committee’s make-up, but did say that she, Director of Equity and Inclusion Erin Maguire and other administrators plan to review the procedures again before putting them in place.
“Beth [Cobb] has offered to work with the board to better share the connection between policy and procedure,” board member Al Bombardier said. “I am looking forward to that education.”
Board member Erin Knox also felt comfortable with this arrangement, and hoped the board would follow in the footsteps of the South Burlington and Champlain Valley school districts and commit to equity.
“There is a system of checks and balances here,” she said. “We are going to get quarterly reports and data points...this is crucial to what we need to do move forward.”
Nearly two hours into the board’s deliberation, member Diane Clemens grew impatient with her colleagues continued qualms.
”I am ready to vote yes,” she said, her voice raised. “Some of these questions should have been forwarded to Erin [Maguire] a while ago, and I’m pissed off at you guys.”
Just before the vote, several board members thanked the community for their involvement. A few also shared their hope that the anger and divisiveness that cropped up at meetings and online would fade.
“Whether you support the work or are opposed, I want to thank you,” board member Brendan Kinney said. “Your involvement ultimately benefits the community and the children we educate in our district.”
Jack Behlendorf, the board’s newest member, said he was not initially in favor of passing the policy, but after listening to the community, asking questions and doing his own research, he decided to vote yes.
“It’s better to have a policy and go forward than to not have one and deal with the issues,” he said. "I am reminded of the Constitution and our country's purpose to strive towards a 'more perfect union.'"
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here