The selectboard nipped and tucked during a marathon budget session Monday night to trim its $1 million budget increase down to about $600,000.
The cuts bring the overall general fund budget to $14.3 million, representing a 4.34 percent increase over the current year.
For the owner of a $280,000 home, that will mean a tax increase of about $41.
The selectboard entered its final budget session staring down a 7.3 percent budget increase from last month’s staff proposal, half of which funded the creation of five new positions: an IT technician, human resources director, two cops and a public works employee.
Staff offered a list of potential cuts at the meeting’s start that would have trimmed this year’s budget increase nearly in half. Much of those savings came from reshuffling start dates for the new positions. For example, by starting the new IT position in March 2019 instead of July 2018, the town will save nearly $60,000 in this year’s budget.
But some members felt it was better to fund some of those positions now instead of staggering them throughout the year, which they said would give the impression of a lower impact in this budget but inevitably raise costs in fiscal year 2020.
The debate flared up most notably during discussions over whether to include the two police officers. The list of potential cuts suggested starting one officer next January and dropping the other position.
But a memo from Chief Rick Garey emphasized the need for new officers in the department, which hasn’t had a staff increase in nearly two decades.
“Understaffing the police department potentially has significant impacts on the quality and quantity of our police work,” Garey wrote. “EPD has become almost completely reactive to calls for service due to our current staffing levels.”
And municipal manager Pat Scheidel said there could be more vacancies looming: Five cops are approaching retirement in the next year or so.
Chairman Max Levy said he supported the phased-in approach, especially given the department’s potential search for up to seven new officers amid previous recruitment challenges.
But selectwomen Irene Wrenner and Sue Cook supported keeping the positions, with Wrenner referencing the recent bill that legalizes marijuana.
“I’m thinking we need more cops for whatever comes down the pike over the next 12 months, not fewer,” Wrenner said.
The board compromised on starting one of the two positions halfway through the fiscal year.
Other notable cuts include a $31,000 transfer to the parks capital plan that will be instead funded through impact fees; $15,600 from the town clerk budget for improvements to the land records systems, which will be paid for with records preservation funds; and $17,000 from the highway and streets vehicles capital budget. Public works director Dennis Lutz said this could be paid for with expected federal funds after last year’s windstorm.
After each member shared their own cuts, the board took a brief recess while finance director Lauren Morrisseau tallied up to the total.
The board then needed to decide if it could stomach the 4.34 percent jump. Levy thought it sounded high.
He said the board needs to give residents something “palatable” and wondered if members could identify any further savings. He circled back to the second police position, which would drop the budget down to 3.99 percent if cut.
But as the meeting entered its fourth hour, little patience remained.
“I’m tired of playing that game, Max. Every year we try to do this,” Wrenner said. “If you want me to present the budget, I’ll present the 4.3 budget, OK?
“I believe really strongly in what we’re charged with doing and that we have to present what it takes,” she continued. “And if people want to come and vote no, that’s their prerogative. But we owe them a fair picture of what’s needed in this town and not some game play, because we’ve played enough games in this town.”
“I think we’re doing what we think is best for the community to give them the services that they need,” Levy responded. “But we’re trying to do it in a way that’s as fiscally responsible as we can do.”
“And I’m more than capable of [presenting the budget],” he added. “I’ve done it many times.”
The meeting closed with similar discord over the board’s final decision: how much fund balance to use.
The proposal offered $125,000, the same amount as last year, to offset tax rates and lessen the impact on homeowners.
Selectman Andy Watts, who previously argued the board has failed to comply with its policy, again pointed to the fund balance surplus. Selectboard policy says any unassigned fund balance over 15 percent must be used to offset future tax rates.
The $125,000 transfer would leave about $140,000 left above the threshold, Watts said.
He feared the selectboard could duck its policy by deciding to assign those funds at some point in the next year, thus removing them from the unassigned column.
“We should return all of the money due to the taxpayers this year so that we don’t have the option of spending it,” he said.
He found little support.
“It’s not like that money is burning a hole in our pocket,” selectman Michael Plageman said. “It sits there to be used toward future taxes, and that’s where it always sits. And then we beat it to death on cut night and then it sits there for another night until the next cut night comes.”
Levy and Scheidel argued the more money that’s put in now, the bigger the gap is next year.
“Once you do that, then you never get that fund balance back,” Scheidel said. “And it’s a very, very bad approach to budgeting.”
Watts said the board should “suck it up and take the hit” if it doesn’t have fund balance for next year, adding, “We keep saying it’s a bad idea to use fund balance year after year. So let’s spend it all … then you don’t have that problem.”
Cook suggested compromising at half of the remaining fund balance, but the board eventually decided to add in $25,000 to the transfer. Watts moved to increase the amount, but no one seconded.
Shortly after, as the board voted to warn a public hearing on the budget, Watts dissented. The motion passed 4-1.
The selectboard will host a public hearing on the proposed budget Monday night at the town offices starting at 7 p.m.
Editor’s note: The online version of this article was updated to clarify proposed staff cuts would have cut the overall budget increase in half.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here