Asbestos causes alarm but no unsafe exposure

Posted

By COLIN FLANDERS

The Essex Town School District had a visit from the Vermont Department of Health last week when parents raised concerns after the school failed to notify them of asbestos removal at Founders Memorial School while students were in the building.

Parents grew frustrated after learning of the project, which was to remove asbestos-containing caulking around windows. The work began July 10, and parents noticed when dropping off their children the next morning.

After hearing the concerns, the district directed the Mansfield Environmental Group, the contractors in charge of the abatement, to halt all work until after 2 p.m. once students and teachers had left the building for the day.

The removal was finished by Friday, July 15, according to superintendent Mark Andrews.

The district was unaware of a 1986 law that requires districts to notify teachers and parents annually regarding asbestos-related activities, Andrews said. This includes inspections and abatements.

Ellen Thompson, director of instruction and information services as well as summer program coordinator, emailed parents July 11 after the project started, allowing them to keep children home if they had concerns.

The contractors were in the back of the school that Monday, she said. The next day, they moved to another section in close proximity to a group of around 25 students, she said.

Parents contacted the state, prompting a visit from Vernon Nelson, chief of the asbestos and lead regulatory program.

After Nelson visited the site and obtained levels from the contractors, he called the concerned parents to let them know there was no unsafe exposure, Thompson said.

Ben Truman, a spokesman for the Vermont Department of Health, assured abatement is not dangerous as long as the contractors follow the appropriate practices to control and prevent the release of asbestos into the environment.

“It’s our finding that they did,” Truman said.

Even so, Thompson understands the alarm whenever asbestos is involved.

“That word conjures up all sorts of fears,” she said.

Asbestos can cause disabling respiratory disease and various types of cancers if the fibers are inhaled, either directly or through fibers from contaminated clothing. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration states symptoms of these diseases generally do not appear for 20 or more years after initial exposure.

The asbestos at Founders Memorial was non-friable, Andrews said, meaning it’s unlikely to result in significant fiber release when handled correctly.

The 1986 Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act requires public school districts to inspect schools for asbestos and prepare management plans.

Per federal guidelines, ETSD also performs surveillance on their known asbestos-containing materials every six months. It’s not a perfect system, however.

“We didn’t even know there was asbestos in Founders until we started the window project,” Andrews said. “You can only check asbestos when you know it’s in your building.”

The district was unaware of the notification requirement, Andrews said, and neither the contractor nor the department of health pointed it out.

“People should have been notified, those who were going to be in the building,” he said.

He noted the district received the necessary permit from the health department, and the contractor had all its permits in order. He stressed Mansfield Environmental did “everything we asked them to do.”

“If there’s any fault to be had, it’s for me not knowing a letter should have gone out beforehand,” Andrews said. “If that had been pointed out to us as a district, by all means — we had no reason not to.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here