As EWSD's school consolidation plans solidify, parents remain divided

Posted

ESSEX WESTFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT — As EWSD faces consolidation, families are expressing mixed feelings about the big changes. 

This past budget cycle brought several major decisions, particularly the repurposing of Summit Street School and the move of Westford’s middle-schoolers to Essex Middle School. 

Summit School students will now attend Hiawatha Elementary School, for a total district cost savings of about $1.5 million. The middle school merger will result in saving $277,000. Westford Elementary was previously home to about 60 students in grades 6-8. 

The decision to consolidate these schools comes partially in response to the fact that locals are actively being driven out by tax rate increases. The school board is faced with keeping the district affordable while providing students with high quality education. 

This year, the school board chose to maintain level net spending for fiscal year 2026, at a total cost of $94.7 million, in an aim to stave off double digit increases for taxpayers. 

“We heard from a lot of folks saying, ‘I would have to leave not just Essex, but probably Vermont,’ based on the taxes they were receiving from last year,” said vice chair of EWSD’s school board Marlon Verasamy of area residents. “They couldn’t afford it.” 

All things said and done, the district had to absorb $6 million worth of cuts district-wide, amidst rising health insurance costs for staff, nationwide concerns about tariffs, and a growing affordability crisis in the state. 

These decisions are happening in tandem with state legislative efforts to push for consolidation, as student enrollments drop in an aging state. 

EWSD has every intention of keeping Westford open and public, so long as the state doesn’t force a decision contrary to local intentions. At the end of the day, and at the end of this legislative session, these choices may fall outside of the board’s hands. 

For the time being, area neighbors have their sights set on what’s to come just around the bend. 

While some parents are pleased with the decision to send their kids to Essex where the more plentiful opportunities are, some Westford parents are skeptical of the board’s intentions, and dissatisfied with the board’s decisions up to this point regarding the future of their small school. 

“We have to find that balance for everybody,” Verasamy said. “The outcomes, we feel, that are going to be the best outcomes for our students, but also we feel going to be the best outcomes for our community too — that we're going to invest in our students, but we're not going to do it to the point where we're going to force community members out because they can't afford it anymore.” 

He and Robert Carpenter, the school board’s chair, both say the cuts their board has made have been executed with equitable dispersion of available resources at the forefront of their minds. 

But what are students' families thoughts on the academic, social and cultural implications of the directive to consolidate their local district? And what does Westford’s selectboard have to say? 

Capacity concerns at Hiawatha  

Linda Hansen, a former Hiawatha teacher, who is also the mother of grown children who went through the school and the grandmother of a current Hiawatha preschool student, is concerned about the repurposing of Summit Street. 

Hansen and her grandson live across the street from Hiawatha, and Hansen is worried the capacity at Hiawatha won’t adequately accommodate all the needs of the elementary students it’s about to absorb. 

Previously, each school served relatively small neighborhood communities of the district’s youngest learners. But naturally — with more students in one spot, come tighter spaces. 

Hiawatha currently has visual art and music in their own respective separate classrooms — but Hansen warns against the dangers of the “art-on-a-cart” model, which is the model Hiawatha will transition its arts classes to this upcoming year as a result of space limitations. 

With both subjects wheeled from room to room, as they had been during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, she’s nervous about the loss of time and space for instruments and equipment that will arise with the move. 

“I would just think this would affect the instruction they would be able to give to the kids,” Hansen told the Reporter. “I'm sure the teachers would adjust, and they would make everything wonderful for the kids, but I think the reality is the quality of instruction will suffer.” 

At a recent school board meeting May 20, six community members including Hansen and district art teacher Amanda Feller, spoke against the recently-solidified art-on-a-cart model. 

Feller taught art at Westford and Summit for many years, and will now teach at Hiawatha, but without a dedicated art room. Art and music will take turns on carts, allowing for five classrooms at each grade level. 

“This isn't just a logistical shift, it's a statement of values and priorities,” Feller said at the meeting. “The [room] shows that art matters and deserves respect — with a cart, that sacred space disappears. Art must fit in a bin. It mustn't take long. It mustn’t make too much of a mess.” 

But what is lost is also the joy she sees pour from kids for whom the artroom is where they feel most seen, or who lack other positive outlets for self-regulation and self expression. 

“The art room isn't just another classroom,” Feller said. “For many students, it's their favorite place in the entire school. Art stands out because it reaches kids who struggle in other settings. For children with IEPs, trauma histories or social emotional needs, the art room provides the most accessible form of academic engagement.” 

Hiawatha will now be the only school in the district without dedicated art and music rooms. 

The school board and administration have made it clear their intent is for the cart-model to be a one-year, temporary solution, as they continue to hear on redistricting or consider other options. 

The board said sacrifices had to be made to prevent tax spikes that could push residents out this year, lest programming elsewhere that is equally-critical be lost. 

Initial plans to reduce the music program and guidance counselor staffing were reversed after the board heard community members on the harms of such a move to elementary students. 

However, requests from a number of outspoken area residents to save Summit School in its current form, or to delay the Westford move, were not accommodated by the school board. 

The board’s position is that delaying or canceling any such plans would create more uncertainty and divisiveness within the community, and that doing so would not be practical or affordable. 

Verasamy said the board is looking into building pods at Hiawatha to add additional space. 

Contractors have reviewed site, construction and utility placement needs. EWSD is now awaiting a quote from Freeman, French and Freeman and will be undergoing a state technical review and bid process. 

The board is also addressing the community’s concerns about parking at Hiawatha. Carpenter, without negating the seriousness of student safety, noted pick-up and drop-off is a “transportation nightmare” — at every school in the district, given that if a lot of parents choose to drop their kids off at school in a single family vehicle, it automatically creates congestion. 

“It's just kind of the reality of the day and age we live in,” Carpenter said. “A lot of people don't walk to school. A lot of people just drive, or very few actually take the bus.” 

There will be about 70 more kids at Hiawatha going forward than there were prior to the change. 

“We completely understand the anxiety,” Verasamy said. “We are very sensitive to it… We're still working on it, and we have the utmost faith in the district that they're going to continue to work on the problem if they see anything that falls into the cracks.” 

Hence, the administration is actively looking into the possibility of changing the configuration of the Hiawatha parking lot to accommodate more traffic, and is working on those details — precisely because they've heard people express their feelings about it, Carpenter said. 

Because people like Hansen fought for there to remain two preschools in Essex Junction, Summit will continue to house two preschool programs, plus the 15 students in EWSD’s ARC program who need a more therapeutic learning setting for the sake of their mental health. 

The preschool at Hiawatha, however, will be closing, in order to accommodate Summit students. 

“For us as a family and for me as a teacher who worked there, it's been a really supportive community,” Hansen said, of Hiawatha. “It's just a lovely environment, both to work in and to be a parent in, and to my children — I loved being there.” 

Hansen describes the school as very welcoming and expects that sentiment to continue to flow through its halls — albeit, more crowded ones — with the influx of new kids to its student body. 

She’s seen firsthand how hard teachers work to meet the individualized needs of every child. But she also believes the change will be hard as class sizes grow in a stagnant-sized space. 

“They'll adjust,” Hansen said. “Kids are resilient. But I guess it's the process that's upsetting me, personally — it's the way it came about that is hard for me. I still don't understand it, and I've been going to all of the meetings.” 

At the March 18 board meeting, Hansen was happy to see board member Christine Gaynor-Patterson make a motion to keep Summit School open — then disappointed when the board collectively voted against keeping the school as-is, after having voted on the budget proposal itself. 

Summit Principal Colleen Birner is slated to resign from her role at the end of this school year. Hiawatha Principal Katherine Grykien took a new position in Burlington as that district’s curriculum director, which she said she chose to do to work in her hometown and in her child’s school district. 

Given changing leadership, Hansen sees now as a bad time to make so many other changes. 

“It's going to be very stressful and it's unsettling for everyone,” Hansen said. “They're looking to the leadership, as anybody would in a situation. You look to the leadership for support and answers and plans. If you don't have that, it's very unsettling.” 

Westford woes 

Kirsten Tyler is one of a number of parents — she, of two middle-schoolers — who has been outspoken at public meetings on behalf of maintaining a local middle school in Westford, even in the wake of the budget having passed by both the board and voters. 

She appreciates Westford for its small class sizes, and its conduciveness to hosting projects across grade levels, with the wide age range yielding abundant mentorship opportunities. 

“My sixth-grader this year wrote a book with a second-grader, and it was all about the second-grader and their superpowers,” Tyler said. “It's been happening for years and years, and it's an amazing, beautiful, cross-collaboration.” 

In addition to the loss of mentorship opportunities, her other biggest fear is funding electric, HVAC and operations for a soon partially-empty building will render the Westford school more vulnerable to a full-on, government-mandated shut-down, due to the 35% cost-per-pupil increase Westford Elementary faces in the wake of this initial move. 

Although Gov. Phil Scott is pushing legislators to consolidate schools and revamp the mechanisms for education funding, Vermont students have testified to the state legislature against the idea of small school closures in recent months. 

“I testified against this bill in the Senate Ed committee,” said EWSD student representative Pankti Desai at the school board’s May 20 meeting. “Giving the Agency of Education full access to school closures and full control over so many integral parts of local school boards is decreasing equitable access in such a humongous way — I can't even begin to describe it.” 

But as the battle over the future of Vermont’s education landscape continues at the State House, some parents still have their sights on the more local aspects of change-making. 

Tyler has heard mumblings about a possible repurposing of Westford Elementary as a nature center or sustainability magnet school — but she sees it as critical the school remain public. 

“To us, that's not our school,” Tyler said. “We need a public school in this town. We're, like, 40 minutes away from Essex… So a magnet school — sure, that sounds great, but we already have a Montessori-type school in our town: the Barn School. We don’t need another.” 

The school board informed the Reporter it has every intention of keeping Westford Elementary a public elementary school, but the now-vacant space in the building could also still become an alternative school program or nature-based school for EWSD students to attend by-choice. 

Transitioning Westford to that kind of structure could keep it off the state’s chopping block. 

“We still have to have those talks with folks that figure out what works best for each community,” Verasamy said. “There's still a lot of room to create something at Westford that I think could be long lasting and may make Westford more appealing and less likely to be in danger of closing.” 

The board would never make a decision to funnel public dollars to private education at closed public schools, even if that’s a plan the governor might like to see play out, Carpenter said. 

There has been a lot of confusion within the community around who is responsible for which plans — for instance, Carpenter said people have advocated for the board to simply renegotiate health insurance for employees, but those costs are handed to them as a lump sum by the state. 

“We don't have any control over that… A lot of those are external forces,” Carpenter said.

The school board has declined requests from Westford parents to sign off on a formal charter amendment committing to a guarantee the school will stay open — because if a state mandate about rural school closures comes their way, closures are likely to be out of the board’s control, Carpenter said. 

This decision to leave the school’s charter as-is was made with input from legal counsel. 

Despite the board’s efforts and vocal promises of its intent, pushback from Westford families and others has continued since the announcement of the consolidation at the start of 2025. 

Tyler describes the entire situation as “very unprecedented,” and has gathered at least 100 signatures on a petition against the move to bring Westford middle-schoolers to Essex Town. There’s also now a petition circulating amongst Westford folks for possibly withdrawing from EWSD. 

Westford joined the district in 2017 with the belief it would benefit the students. Though they’d be fighting an uphill battle against the state to leave now, some Westford residents are rethinking whether EWSD membership is in the best interest of their town and their students. 

Though Tyler has been told loose plans are in place — like the nature school, which has not been a good solution in her eyes — the uncertainty has been anything but reassuring, she said. 

But Carpenter remains firm in reiterating the school board’s stance. 

“I understand where that anxiety comes from, of, ‘Is this just a precursor to closure?’” Carpenter said. “And it's not. Our board last year had to cut $4.5 million. And some people in the community were saying, just cut Westford. That would solve the issue right there.” 

“We chose not to,” he added. “We cut from other places. This year we had to cut $6 million. Some people came out again and said, ‘Just close Westford completely,’ and we said, "No, we want to keep an elementary school, but then let's make the [middle school] shift.” 

Tyler pointed out that amidst promises of cost savings, the move is slated to result in just a one-time savings of $277,000 out of a total budget of $96 million, only to result in increased class sizes for middle-schoolers, not to mention anticipated increases in transportation costs. 

Carpenter, however, said the additional transportation costs will be minimal, because it's a direct line bus that's going straight back and forth from Westford to EMS, as opposed to racking up mileage all over town throughout multiple neighborhoods, as most of the district’s bus lines do. 

But the middle school consolidation was much more about giving Westford students further opportunities than it was about savings, Carpenter said. A number of Westford families already wanted their children to make the shift to EMS, where more expansive opportunities are. 

Now, transportation will be provided to those students as part of the EWSD budget, which it wasn’t before. Although Westford students already had the choice to go to EMS if they wanted, the lack of busing prior could have inhibited those with the desire. 

Going forward, that gap will be bridged by taxpayers, Carpenter said. 

But one of the other major concerns of Westford parents is they expect to see their kids on a bus for much longer times than other students in the district.

Tyler and others view the lengthened transportation time to arrive at school as the most major equity issue now, given Westford’s center is about 12 miles away from Essex Middle School. 

Currently, high schoolers in Westford are bussed to Westford Elementary from their respective neighborhoods, then bused to Essex High School. 

Superintendent Beth Cobb asked the district’s Transportation Committee to take a look at making adjustments to the morning pickup and afternoon drop off locations, number of stops and more, to optimize routes and travel times as well as overall reliability for students in the district, and increased access to morning activities. 

“Bus rides for the middle school remain roughly about the same as they currently are, about 50 minutes, which includes the trip to EMS,” she said at the May 20 school board meeting. “The bus ride home is 45 to 50 minutes.” 

However, Brian Donahue, the district’s COO, has noted at previous public meetings he believes EWSD’s transportation system is flawed as it is, and not likely to improve anytime soon. 

“Our transportation doesn’t meet needs and in some cases doesn’t meet some parents’ needs at all,” he said at a February school board meeting. “I heard the concerns of Westford… I hear it regularly that the transportation does not adequately meet our needs, and I’m afraid to say it’s most likely gonna get worse.” 

Earlier on in the budgeting process, the Westford selectboard had voted unanimously to share several statements with the EWSD school board. In a Feb. 18 letter, selectboard member Pat Haller said Westford Elementary is the only public-school building in Westford and is near the town center — but that it can take over 20-30 minutes for most residents to get to it, and even longer during mud-season. 

“During the best seasons, moving any grades away would be a significant burden on our

students and families,” Heller stated at the time. “We thank you for your hard cost-cutting efforts, we know very well how difficult some choices are, and at times choices can come with unintended consequences. 

The letter states the presence and use of the Westford school directly impacts Westford’s financial stability, and states many of its residents re-located to Westford to be there. 

“We must recognize that a strong tax base results from vibrant, attractive schools and is in our collective best interest,” Haller wrote, before the decision had been finalized. “We implore you to not reduce the grades at the Westford School because we believe the consequences would be devastating to our town, which is exactly the impetus that drove us in 2017 to join forces.” 

The Westford selectboard expressed a desire to collaborate with EWSD to strategize around taking advantage of the school’s setting, surrounded by nearly 200 acres of town-owned protected forestland, which could be “complimentary and attractive” to district-wide learning. 

There was also a forum among Westford parents in early April, with a few news outlets and a UVM professor of sociology, to discuss the move. The school board was invited to hear out Westford constituents’ perspectives, though none of the school board members attended — the board’s rationale being that a decision had already been made, with no opportunity for a revote. 

But the intent to collaborate on forward-thinking solutions is very much there, Carpenter said. 

Excitement for opportunities ahead 

Jodi Mashia, a mother of two middle school students at Westford Elementary, is pro-consolidation of the middle schools, and is excited to see her kids flourish just one town away from home. 

“It's been a great experience,” she said. “We've loved the school, but as we got into middle school, we found there are just less offerings.” 

While some parents feel the solution is to invest more in Westford Elementary’s offerings, Mashia recognizes the comparatively small population of the Westford school doesn’t warrant taking resources away from more densely populated schools elsewhere in the district. 

“They can't offer the number of clubs that EMS can, because we don't have the kids to fill them,” she said. “There's just only so much that can happen with a class size of 20 kids.”

But while she respects the differing viewpoints of all Westford parents, the increased access to more opportunities and options is just half of the positive she sees of the middle school transfer. 

“With my daughter's seventh grade class, she's been with the same 20 kids, for all these years of school, and it can feel pretty small after awhile,” Mashia said. “Luckily, they have a good group, so it hasn't been bad, but there's no escaping.” 

Meeting students in Essex Town prior to high school could be beneficial for Westford students. Verasamy said freshmen at EHS who transitioned from Westford Elementary overwhelmingly told the board they felt unprepared to make that transition going directly from a rural elementary school to a three-community high school. 

Now, the transition will happen in phases, from one small elementary school, to a slightly bigger middle school, to a larger high school. 

In the long run, Mashia sees it as the best possible outcome for Westford’s middle-schoolers — even if the prospect of such a major shift came as a surprise to her at first, albeit a happy one. 

“I started to kind of feel like we were missing out here… I think that what actually led to a lot of surprise for me was the amount of people who are against it,” she said. “A lot of those people were the ones leading the cause in not being happy with the opportunities in Westford.” 

The middle school opportunities that currently differ from school to school are as follows: 

WES: 

  • Soccer, basketball and volleyball offered as sports for grades 6-8; 

  • Robotics team the only club offering, with five teams building-wide; 

  • Algebra class offered online-only through VTVLC; 

  • Physical education, health class, Spanish, band and chorus, visual arts and social emotional learning — with unified arts classes offered five days a week. 

EMS: 

  • Soccer, field hockey, cross country, basketball, cheerleading, intramural volleyball, intramural ultimate frisbee, basketball, softball, track and field, and access to a certified weight room for physical education across grades 6-8; 

  • Chess, Dungeons and Dragons, football, gender-sexuality alliance, Magic the Gathering, science club, fly tying and fishing, weightlifting, and one team for robotics — clubs change from year to year based on student interests; 

  • Student leadership opportunities through an athletic leadership council, youth leadership team and national junior honor society; 

  • Algebra offered four days a week with an in-person instructor; 

  • Physical education, health, Spanish, French, performing arts, applied mathematics, technical skills, visual arts and digital citizenship instruction for 6th grader specifically — unified arts classes are offered for 40 minutes daily with one day of UA extension and intervention opportunity offered weekly. 

“Just to see my kids have more opportunities and make new friends and new memories and new opportunities, both with peers — and our teachers are amazing — but with more teachers and different teachers,” Mashia said. “I think that this new opportunity will just be a great experience.” 

A changing state landscape 

In Montpelier, school talks stalled this past weekend after legislators couldn’t come to a compromise on H.454, this session’s landmark education bill. 

Gov. Scott’s administration proposed sweeping changes, including moving to just five districts statewide and a new funding formula, back in January, but legislators have since debated the details. 

The legislative session had been set to close last Friday, but talks will now stretch into the summer. 

“We always knew transforming our education system wouldn’t be easy, and it’s clear a little more time is needed to get the job done well,” Scott, Speaker Jill Krowinski and Senate President Pro Tempore Phil Baruth said in a joint statement Monday. 

“We remain committed to working together to find a path forward in the coming weeks that achieves better outcomes for our kids at a rate taxpayers can afford. We look forward to continuing the conversation with members to have a proposal in June that works for a bipartisan majority of both the House and the Senate.” 

Carpenter and Verasamy encourage EWSD community members to focus on what’s happening at the state level, and to find unity in speaking out on behalf of protecting their local district. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here