As county forester promotes plan for Essex woodlands, some question the need

Posted

When Chittenden County forester Ethan Tapper inherited a new office a year-and-a-half ago, piles of old newspaper clippings and historic documents for Saxon Hill and Indian Brook came with it.

To create a comprehensive timeline, Tapper solicited five University of Vermont capstone students — Caroline Drayton, Greg Lizotte, Mathew Mitchell, Liam Gerry and Alex Frayer — to compile a historic narrative.

The goal is to increase public awareness about Essex’s town forests, Tapper said.

“History really informs forest management in a lot of ways,” he said. “And the other part of it is to engage folks and open people’s eyes to the fact that these forests exist and what a great resource they are.”

Tapper, in conjunction with the Essex Conservation Committee, recently constructed an Indian Brook forest management plan, where public awareness again plays a large role, he said. The selectboard approved the plan 4-1 earlier this month, with selectwoman Irene Wrenner opposing.

The timely alignment of the students’ project, the forest management plan and the town’s reacquisition of 245 acres in Saxon Hill garner opportunity for residents to learn more about town forests, Tapper said.

The students sifted through Tapper’s files, which sit near a 1981 map of Saxon Hill — then the Essex Jct. Town Forest. Last month, the forester traced a yellowed newspaper from the late 1970s, headlining a Saxon Hill sale.

The students detailed Indian Brook and Saxon Hill’s long landowner histories. Saxon Hill records even document when every tree was planted, where it came from, who planted it and every time it was cut.

The students sought out town resources and insight from local boards to build the narrative, which will be posted on the town website by month’s end, community development planner Darren Schibler said.

On December 12, the students presented their report to the conservation and trails committee, which was generally “very excited to have the history put into one place and done in a way that shows the development of land over time — who owned it when and how it came to be what it is today,” Schibler said.

The student’s compilation will help the town create a future management plan for Saxon Hill.

The new Indian Brook plan, Tapper said, increases educational opportunities about town forests.

Some residents at the Jan. 2 selectboard meeting questioned parts of the plan, particularly that Tapper recommended logging for the area.

Resident Daniel Stein said he’d rather let Mother Nature take its course than allow commercial logging. Selectwomen Irene Wrenner questioned the plan from a climate change standpoint and also worried the monetary benefits outweigh the environmental effect.

Expecting these concerns, Tapper said his “only skin in the game” is managing town forests responsibly.

Tapper offered his team’s work at Bolton’s Preston Pond Conservation Area as an example. Before the project’s timber sale, he’s inviting community members to walk around with him and learn why he’s marked certain trees for cutting. When the logger’s halfway done, he’ll do the same. And when the project’s complete, he’ll do it again a third time.

Tapper said the data he collected in the field shows his recommendations will improve the quality of the forests for both humans and wildlife.

Some Essex residents remain skeptical. Ethnobotanist and educator Judy Dow advocated for the forest’s natural state, questioning the ongoing removal of invasive species.

According to the plan, harvesting would occur between 2019 and 2025. Wrenner worries such human intervention and destruction could be an unnatural approach.

The plan also encourages deer hunting to cull Indian Brook’s high deer population. With last year’s firearms forums in mind, Wrenner was wary some residents wouldn’t support the decision.   

Non-foresters — like environmentalists and ecologists — should be brought into the conversation before the town officially adopts the plan, Wrenner stressed. She said she voted against the plan as a call to look deeper into the issue.

“Just because we’re the humans here doesn’t necessarily mean we only have to look at the human considerations,” Wrenner said. “If we’re wise about this planet, we’ll start listening to different voices.”

Tapper said most Chittenden County towns have become more conservation-minded. Longtime residents and newcomers appreciate conservation differently, Tapper said, but are united in preserving healthy forests and landscapes.

Schibler said forestry isn’t just about creating revenue opportunities for timber sales, but improving forest health, too.

“We hope [the students’ narrative] inspires a little more connection to those areas,” he said.

Visit http://bit.ly/2o2bXZ1 for the historic narrative of Indian Brook and Saxon Hill.

essex conservation committee, essex history, ethan tapper, forest management plan, indian brook, saxon hill

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here