Application denied: Essex votes down Amazon facility proposed for Saxon Hill

Posted

ESSEX TOWN — After several months and many hours-long meetings, the Essex Development Review Board voted to deny a pending application to build an Amazon fulfillment center in town. 

With one DRB member absent last night, the DRB still voted 4-2 against approval. Had it been approved, it would have become the first brick-and-mortar Amazon facility in Vermont. 

After an hour of private deliberations, the decision was announced at 9:08 p.m. to cheers from the crowd in attendance. 

The DRB’s stated reasons for deliberations being conducted behind closed doors included the expectation of interruption by the public and alleged threats to the safety of certain DRB members after unsolicited calls were made to members’ personal phones. 

“This has been a hotly contested item,” said DRB Chair Ian Carroll. 

The private deliberative session remains open, only to allow the final DRB member not present last night, Stephanie Bixby, the opportunity to weigh in. Whether the vote becomes 4-3 or 5-2, the decision still stands with a majority being “no” votes. 

The meeting adjourned promptly after this announcement. 

“Please know this board has weighed this application very heavily, and that any decisions that we hand out this evening is based on the merits of the application and the current zoning regulations only,” Carroll said. “This has been a long process for applicants, developers, residents and ourselves.” 

“A motion was made to approve the application and it failed,” he added. 

The facility had been proposed as a 107,000 square-foot fulfillment center with 482 parking spaces on 22.94 acres of woodlands at 637 Kimo Drive, off of Thompson Drive and in the industrially-zoned section of Saxon Hill Forest. The project’s developer, Scannell, had also been seeking a waiver for the required 50-foot buffer between the property and Kimo Drive. 

The proposal drew much contention from the public — with protestors holding signs with their sentiments against the development at each meeting and the final segment of the public hearing last night. 

Over 80 people attended the continued public hearing yesterday, many of whom spoke out. 

Previous public hearings were held March 20, May 29 and June 26, and attempted May 1. 

Concerns raised at Thursday’s meeting preceding the decision included the need for Act 250 review, the ecological health and habitat security of native wildlife in the forest, the feeling that the town would become an “experiment” by way of accepting the facility, concerns about the possibility of waiving the buffer requirements for this applicant, deforestation, traffic worries for the area especially during school dismissals, plus vehicle speed and children’s safety. 

Also of concern to the public is the lack of enforceability around construction traffic monitoring, the fact that if something were to go wrong the facility will still be there with the megacorporation able to weather any lawsuit, and distrust in Amazon’s claims that the facility is too “unique” to replicate precisely in a better traffic study. 

The center had been advertised as a “last mile” facility despite the fact that it’s seven miles just to get to the nearest highway and that the facility would be servicing 105 zip codes, an inaccurate euphemism which also concerned some folks, among other ways the public feared the development would alter life in their small town. 

Phoenix Books had put out an open letter to town officials July 14 to call on the town manager, selectboard and DRB to “stop this choice before it is too late,” garnering around 400 signatures. 

The DRB at a previous meeting had requested Amazon provide a more realistic traffic study.

There’s since been debate within the DRB over whether the answers provided were satisfactory. 

Essex resident Anne Miller, who coordinated the recent founding of new community-based non-profit ACRES in response to the Amazon proposition, told the Reporter her group was thrilled at what they view as a victory for the Town, when the decision came back a no. 

“It was just amazing,” she said. “This project was never going to be defeated on moral outrage, we needed to line up the facts and work with the existing Town Plan and zoning regulations and demonstrate how what was being proposed didn’t align with what we’ve said we want as a town.” 

So, ACRES dug into the traffic details and hired what she believes are the best environmental lawyers in the state, providing them the necessary information to argue their group’s case. 

“But we’re not done,” she said. “We’re just getting started.” 

Next Thursday from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m., ACRES will attend an Act 250 hearing for a separate proposal the lower lot of the subdivision in question on Kimo Drive, and the group will continue to tune into discussions about other development projects slated for DRB discussion — with diverse, harmonious land use and value-adding operations as a priority, and the intention to become more proactive than reactive on future community development and growth initiatives. 

“We want human-scaled development for, for Essex, not oversized, we want lower taxes,” Miller said. “We want well paying jobs. We want affordable housing.” 

Miller got involved in organized opposition because she felt in earlier discussions that very knowledgeable neighbors were speaking up and not being heard by the town government. 

“You shouldn’t have to be rich to be heard,” she said. “These people live here and they deserve a voice… All credit goes to the team. They’re an amazing group of people.” 

More detailed reasons for nixing the project will be issued online in near-future DRB packets. 

Although no official requests to work with other municipalities have been made public, other municipalities have already expressed tentative interest in hosting the Amazon facility. 

The Reporter will run rationale in an update soon, when more information becomes available. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here