A positive endorsement for the future of our community

Posted

This letter is meant to be a positive endorsement for the future of our community. I should first admit that having been a Village resident for seventeen years and a Town resident for the past four years, I have generally favored merger, but I felt I needed to better understand the argument for opposing the merger before I voted. I first looked to the group that funded the “no merger” flyer that went out in our mail last week. The first line on their webpage at nomergernow.org states, “Follow the money.” As it never really traces out all the balance sheets like the Greater Essex voter information booklet, it seemed less informational and more like an effort to discredit the hard work of our Selectboard by implying nefarious backroom deals going on in the political channels of our community. Nevertheless, I read on.

Later on the main page, they quote Senator Mitt Romney as saying, “The best way we can show respect for voters is by telling them the truth.” Again, this seemed to imply that we the voters are NOT being told the truth, but it did not inform me of anything. I read through the 48-page informational document issued by our Selectboard, outlining what members of the Town and Village have to gain and lose by merger, and we have now recently had two highly transparent remote Town meetings, allowing time for people on both sides of this argument to state their case. I do not feel lied to by the Selectboard.

Further down the page, I read that, “The Village’s current fiscal challenges can only be addressed by cutting expenses and resetting priorities among Village residents, not by shifting taxes onto others.” So this is where I began to feel even less informed and more confused. Aside from the potentially unfair accusation of fiscal irresponsibility, I found myself confronted with the assertion that the proposed merger is shifting more Village taxes onto Town taxpayers.

Up until this point, it was my understanding that Village taxpayers pay the same Town general tax as Town taxpayers at a rate of 0.5067, some of this for services they don’t receive, and on top of a Village tax of 0.3026. It is also my understanding that if the Village were to completely separate from the Town, my Town municipal taxes would immediately increase by a substantially larger amount than the incremental annual adjustment proposed by this merger plan over 13 years. In effect, the Town would suddenly lose the 0.5067 subsidy currently paid by every Village taxpayer to the Town. What I could not find on this page was a proposal by nomergernow.org on how Town taxpayers would deal with this much more abrupt and substantial rise in our municipal taxes should the Village separate from the Town. I could only find a number of efforts to discredit the Selectboard. The Village voted on what they felt to be an unfair tax burden from the Town, and the Selectboard was accountable for proposing a solution. This merger is a solution. What then is plan B if this merger fails to pass? Will it be dauntless campaigning to prevent the Village from separating, to hold them hostage to continue subsidizing the Town’s taxes?

After going to nomergernow.org, I did not feel informed. After reading the 48-page booklet issued by the Selectboard, I felt informed. I for one am not voting for a “tax increase.” No one “wants” an increase in taxes, but we need to find a way to gently move toward a place of greater equity. This merger provides a solution, with an annual incremental adjustment over 13 years. I will be voting “Yes” to one community, and “Yes” to a balanced adjustment toward greater equity. I urge our community members to read the Voter Information booklet provided by our Selectboard. Look away from the slander of our Selectboard members and simply look at the facts, they are all in there. Then make your own informed decision.

Gil Allen

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here