A civic duty (and a grade to go with it)

Posted

Local officials may have some electoral competition from a group of civic-minded individuals in the coming years — once they’re of age, that is.

For now, they can simply take note of the advice from students in Amanda Eldridge’s eighth-grade classes who dug into an ongoing question between Essex’s two legislative boards: What would it look like if one governing board covered both the town and village?

The project, as part of a civics unit on local government, prompted a three-week long investigation that forced students to consider how governance structures best serve a community, the purpose of government and the principles required for doing it well. Among the popular: accountability, transparency and equity, plus a desire to spark more participation from constituents.

It’s a way for students to engage in “authentic” learning, Eldridge said, connecting lessons in the classroom to the outside world.

“They’re very excited about the idea that what they’re saying matters to the adults they’re talking to, and it’s not theoretical,” she said. “There’s a different sense of seriousness to it when they know that it’s a discussion that’s happening with grown-ups.”

Her classes started out by learning about the history of Essex, the structures of local governments and the current scenario in the town and village.

They each explored one of six Vermont towns — Barre, Bennington, Burlington, Colchester, Montpelier or Rutland — in which they spoke with local officials about the pros and cons of their varied forms of government. That included city councils, managers, mayors and a mix of all three.

Students also had to interview a few other adults, including parents, to learn more about how citizens navigate different governing structures.

They then created a town profile that identified a form of government, election system, number of representatives on the legislative board and how long they would serve.

The most common form during one session last Thursday was the council/manager system — surely welcome news for Essex’s incoming manager. Most preferred a seven-councilor board with a mix of at-large candidates and those elected on a district/ward scenario. And nearly all agreed on the government’s purpose: to make life better for its citizens.

On hand to offer feedback for the presentations was a shifting panel of local officials. During one morning session, that included village president George Tyler, selectboard chairman Max Levy and municipal manager Pat Scheidel.

Eldridge says the topic could have easily taken up another month of class, though she feels students greatly benefit from even a limited exposure to such a dense topic.

Many students started to understand change is nothing to fear, though it does requires patience and commitment. And they began recognizing themes in the news to make connections to current events beyond their own community boundaries.

“So they’re getting a little indignant about issues, and it’s really cool to have those conversations with them,” Eldridge said.

The local government study precedes Eldridge’s citizenship project, where students are required to perform 10 hours of community service to inspire civic engagement at an early age.

The project allows students to experience what it’s like to express ideas they expect will be heard and respected, Eldridge said. And it helps reach some students who have become disengaged at some point in the school year.

Eldridge said kids often underestimate themselves because American culture dismisses the voice of youth on serious issues, including politics.

She finds that by empowering instead of sheltering students, they will grow up to embrace the civic process and see that “dismissing them is not an option.”

She finds that by empowering students instead, they will grow up to embrace the civic process and see that “dismissing them is not an option.”

“If I can do that,” Eldridge said, “if I can open the eyes and ears of adults to see their kids in a different way — as resources — and empower the kids in that process, then that’s why I feel like it’s important.”

essex, essex town, essex village, government, history, town government

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here