'A burst bubble': Vermont has long been seen as a climate haven. That perception may be changing.

Posted

CHITTENDEN COUNTY — Joel and Jessica Nevarez moved their family to Essex from southern California in 2017. After several decades, they’d gotten tired of the traffic, drought and wildfires that affected their life on the West Coast. 

The family was used to climate crises. They usually saw at least two large wildfires in their area per year and experienced both minor and strong earthquakes, with the largest Joel remembers being around a 6.7 on the Richter scale. 

Joel described their feelings to the Reporter about their home state’s climate risks as a bit of  desensitization; it was normal for neighbors and friends to have specialty hose nozzles to put out fires, and for life to carry on as normal in spite of climate challenges. 

At their previous home in California, located in Desert Hot Springs, Joel and Jessica saw temperatures rise as high as 120-some degrees Fahrenheit. The couple knew then they had to make a change.

After seeing something on TV about Vermont, the two started to do more research on moving to the Green Mountain State. The family had always wanted to live among the greenery and nature that the state had to offer, different from the dried out climate they knew. 

The story of how the Nevarezs made their way to Vermont is becoming less and less unique. Around the world and the United States, those who have had their lives uprooted by droughts, wildfires or floods are seeking refuge elsewhere. 

Called “climate migration,” it doesn’t seem like the trend is going to slow down. 

Climate migration in the United States

A 2018 study from the Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists predicted climate risks would be a primary factor in the migration of populations around the United States to places deemed “less susceptible to extreme climate.” 

Already, Americans seem to be moving due to the climate. A 2024 Forbes Home survey found that 30% of American survey respondents cited worsening weather conditions as a reason for their recent move. 

As for where to move to? Vermont is a seemingly sensible choice. 

The Green Mountain State consistently ranks among the safest states from climate risks in various studies. Safe Home ranked Vermont as the lowest state on the risk index for climate change in 2024, while ProPublica data from 2020 put nearby Lamoille, Orange, Franklin and Essex counties as some of the safest in the entire country from climate risks. 

With that in mind, it’s no surprise the Nevarezs decided on Vermont. They’re not the only ones. 

Burlington-based real estate agent Cindy Adair told the Reporter she is seeing more and more of her clients moving to Vermont due to environmental concerns. Post COVID-19, it’s been many of her clients’ main reasons for relocating.

“I just kind of find it an interesting phenomenon, with all the people that came to Vermont because of [COVID-19], but then it kept coming, and it seemed more and more to me that it was environmental people,” Adair said.

She’s had clients from all over. Clients from Colorado looked for a Vermont timeshare through Adair because they were so tired of all the smoke blowing in from West Coast wildfires. Clients from Austin wanted to move to Vermont because they were tired of being afraid that if their air conditioning went out they would have an emergency. 

The list goes on, Adair said. Another family is looking to leave their Cape Cod home for Vermont due to erosion on the coast of Massachusetts. And recent clients of hers are trying to sell their house in New Orleans to escape rising sea levels.

“They are just exhausted from it,” she said. “They’re exhausted from having to worry about every hurricane being a problem for them. It’s just been too much for too long.”

Adair also checks the “Moving to Vermont” community Facebook page almost everyday. Page users post their reasons for moving to Vermont and their questions about the state. Several posts detail users’ plans to move to the state due to heat or wildfires in their current areas. 

Those who are looking to move within the United States are looking for climate stability, Adair said. And Florida and Louisiana’s frequent flooding, or California’s wildfires, don’t provide that stability. 

“It’s such a huge investment for people to put it into something so risky. Would I be running to Florida to buy something? Hell, no,” she said.

Vermont’s climate, after the floods 

While Vermont has long been seen as a climate haven, recent weather events have proved the state is not as impervious as it may have once seemed. 

Hurricane Irene in 2011 was the worst the state had seen since the Great Flood of 1927; the 2011 event damaged thousands of homes and road segments and thousands of acres of farmland. It also claimed the lives of seven Vermonters.

Flash forward 12 years, and flooding also devastated areas of the state in July of last year, with flash flooding and river flooding due to heavy rainfall damaging homes, roads and bridges in places like Montpelier and Barre in central Vermont and Weston and Ludlow in southern Vermont. 

The state was also hit with flooding in July of this year. Though less severe than the year prior, 2024’s Hurricane Beryl brought flooding to the northern part of the state on the anniversary of last year’s destruction. 

Dramatic flooding events like these are starting to change Vermont’s perception as a safe place, said Pablo S. Bose, a climate migration scholar and professor of geography and geosciences at the University of Vermont. 

“There’s been this perception the last five to 10 years that Vermont is maybe a climate-safe place to go. But I think this has punctured that. This has burst that bubble a little bit,” Bose said. 

In her work, Adair is beginning to see Vermont flooding be somewhat of a concern for clients, too. 

Some clients have started to shy away from looking for Vermont real estate in areas hit hard by flooding, like Montpelier and Barre. She’s seen clients’ climate awareness grow, taking more time to understand how streams or ponds near their property could impact them.

“Hurricane Irene was like a flash-in-the-pan, freak situation, and I think people kind of dismissed it as that,” Adair said. “But now we’ve had a couple more rounds, it’s looking more like a common concern.”

Looking to the future 

Dramatic flooding events like these are not “once in every 100 year” occurrences anymore, Bose said. And because of that, officials now need to be addressing the state’s aging infrastructure, and thinking about how more frequent flooding could affect it, he said. 

Though upgrades have continued over the past few years to Burlington sewer and drainage systems to better handle flooding, the same resilient building model needs to be looked at in smaller towns across the state, Bose said. With flooding having hit vulnerable populations in the Northeast Kingdom and in small mountain towns in central Vermont, it’s an important question. 

“And what does this mean for your drinking water quality? What does this mean for the roads that we have?” he asked. 

How recent flooding will impact climate migration to Vermont is difficult to tell, Bose said. Numbers on climate migration are difficult to track, as many who move for environmental reasons also have other reasons for moving between states, he said.

But with this change in perception of  Vermont’s immunity from climate risks, along with housing constraints throughout the state, it is possible Vermont will not maintain its title as a climate haven in the years to come. 

As for the Nevarezs, they maintain that their climate situation in Vermont is much better than where they came from in California. 

The Nevarez family home is on a hill in Essex, and thus did not experience flooding from the summer flooding events of the last two years. But heavy rainfall has caused some erosion on their property, with some doors to the house not shutting properly. 

“I’m worried about that, because of how it’s hurting my home,” Joel said. “We want to stay here for the long haul…it’s going to be all dependent on how things start to affect us.” 

#ernltop, essex, chittenden county, climate, climate migration

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here