ESSEX JUNCTION — Approximately 60 people showed up at a public hearing about the proposed rental registry ordinance during City Council’s Wednesday night meeting.
Most community members who spoke were strongly opposed to the registry, which if adopted, would catalog and inspect Essex Junction apartments.
“I take care of my own apartment for the owner, and they treat me right and I treat them right,” John Provoncha, a local tenant, said. “Essex Junction seems like one of the cleanest and best places to be. There’s not a good reason to be doing this…”
Only a few spoke in favor.
Before the public hearing began, community development Director Chris Yuen shared a slideshow describing what the program would involve.
The registry would create a database of long and short-term rentals landlords would have to register with the City. A city official would inspect all registered units a minimum of every five years to ensure the health and safety of tenants, Yuen said.
The inspector would use the Vermont Residential Rental Housing Health and Safety Code to make decisions about the safety of the unit. Landlords would have to pay $120 per unit per year for this program, and if violations were not fixed in three months, they would also have to pay a $120 fee.
Units that have more violations would be inspected more frequently than those that don’t.
Yuen estimated there are approximately 1,954 rental units in Essex Junction based on data from the City's grand list. This municipal document has information about the city's housing stock which is often used to calculate property tax rates.
Several dozen members of the community shared their thoughts about the rental registry with the council during the Jan. 24 public hearing.
Bridget Downey-Meyer read from a post she made on Front Porch Forum in favor of the rental registry and spoke positively about working with Winooski’s rental registry program as a landlord.
“Winooski established a rental registry about a decade ago, and the quality of housing stock has improved tenfold since then,” she said. “This is a public health and safety issue and deserves to be implemented for the common and community good.”
But many members of the public said they were concerned landlords would pass the registry fees to tenants who tend to already struggle with the cost of living. Many also think the City inspections would be duplicative, as other inspections by the state regarding lead and other health concerns already cover these issues.
There was also concern about the increased cost and time burden for landlords and the creation of municipal bureaucracy. Sean Handy, a local landlord, thought the registry could have the unintended consequence of displacing tenants.
“You're going to find situations where tenants have created their own horrors,” Handy said. “I feel this is going to create situations where landlords are going to be put in the position where the only answer is going to be to get rid of the tenant.”
Jess Wislowski expressed her worry that the ordinance would make things harder for landlords who own fewer units.
“Many of these people are nearing retirement age and this is how they are planning to pay for retirement,” she said.
Lee Barnett said he was against the ordinance from a civil liberties standpoint and had an understanding of the issue as a local social studies teacher.
“I think this is a massive grab of power by the government,” he said. “It’s an intrusion of our private property rights, one of the foundations of America.”
City Council decided not to act on the ordinance and to deliberate later on specific elements of the program, including whether it should be structured under the fire department or community development department and what staffing it would look like.
City Manager Regina Mahoney also clarified the program is cost neutral to the City, as the inspector would be paid by the $120 per unit annual fee from the landlords. This means that the position would not impact future municipal expenditures
The council will discuss the rental registry again during its Feb. 14 meeting. You can watch the Jan. 24 meeting recorded by Town Meeting TV on YouTube here: http://tinyurl.com/yc3u7vwz. More information about the City’s rental registry can be found on its website at bit.ly/EJRentalRegistry.
Correction: This article was updated at 5 p.m. Friday, Jan. 26 and again at 9:15 a.m. Monday, Jan. 29 to correct the name of an individual who spoke during the public hearing. Charlie Burnett was not present. Lee Barnett was. The Reporter apologizes for the error.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here